Simić v. Bosnia and Herzegovina
Tagiyev and Huseynov v. Azerbaijan
Otto-Preminger-Institut v. Austria
Duplicates for corresponding law references
Calvary Chapel Dayton Valley v. Steve Sisolak
Fields v. City of Philadelphia
Previous Summary and Outcome for District Court Ruling
The Eastern District Court of Pennsylvania held that video recording or photographing police activity without the intent to protest, chronicle, criticize or challenge the activity does not constitute expressive conduct protected under the First Amendment. In separate incidents, citizens Fields and Geraci each photographed police officers performing their duties as observers with no stated purpose or message in taking the photos. For conduct to receive first amendment protections, the putative speaker must engage in direct and expressive actions to convey a message, belief or criticism which is likely to be understood by those who see it. The Court found no basis to craft a new First Amendment right based solely on “observing and recording” without expressing a clear message understood by the police or other bystanders. However, the Court noted that several other Circuits have interpreted expressive conduct more broadly to include mere observation based on the belief that gathering information on what public officials do on public property constitutes scrutiny which can prevent abuses.
Esha Bhandari: Developments in U.S. Law – Government Speech Doctrine; Online Speech
Below is an excerpt from Esha Bandari’s presentation given at the annual Justice for Free Expression on 4 April, 2016. Download the full pdf version…
Global Trends in Freedom of Expression Jurisprudence in 2014
New Release! Paper prepared for JUSTICE FOR FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION in 2014 Columbia University, 10-11 March 2015 Introduction A year ago, when we met for…
The Right to Insult in International Law
Abstract States all over the world are enacting new laws that criminalize insults, and using existing insult laws with renewed vigour. In this article, we…
I&JPN: Cross-Border Content Moderation Toolkit
In the absence of clear common guidelines and due process mechanisms, protecting human rights and freedom of expression when dealing with content abuses…